Skip to main content

Table 2 Methodological characteristics of the studies analyzed

From: Efficacy of extracorporeal shock waves therapy for erectile dysfunction treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Authors

Design

Sample size

Intervention

Number of sessions

(Frequency)

P

D

(mm)

F (Hz)

I

(mJ/mm2)

LE

Experimental group

Control group

Olsen et al. (2014) [24

RCT

105

ESWT

Placebo ESWT + applicator

5 (1 session/week)

3000

---

5

0.15

I

Yee et al. (2014) [33

RCT

58

ESWT

Placebo ESWT

12 (2 sessions/week)

1500

18

2

0.09

I

Kitrey et al. (2016) [32

RCT

55

ESWT + PDEI-5

Placebo ESWT

12 (2 sessions/week)

1500

---

2

0.09

I

Fojecki et al. (2017) [26

RCT

118

ESWT

Placebo ESWT

10 (1 session/week)

600

10

5

0.09

I

Qi et al. (2017) [35

QES

60

Group 1: ESWT

Group 2: Vacuum erection device

---

8 (2 sessions/week)

1500

---

2

---

IV

Sramkova et al. (2017) [27

RCT

60

ESWT

Placebo ESWT + gel

4 (2 sessions/week)

6000

15

---

0.16

I

Kalyvianakis et al. (2018) [34

QES

Phase 1: 42

Phase 2: 36

ESWT

---

Phase 1: 6/12 (1-2 sessions/week)

Phase 2: 6 (2-1 sessions/week)

5000

---

8

0.05

IV

Zewin et al. (2018) [37

RCT

128

ESWT

PDEI-5

12 (2 sessions/week)

1500

---

2

0.09

I

Baccaglini et al. (2019) [36

RCT

77

ESWT + PDEI-5

PDEI-5

8 (1 session/week)

2400

40

5

0.09

I

Vinay (2019) [28

RCT

76

ESWT

ESWT + bandage

4 (1 session/week)

5000

---

---

0.09

I

Kim et al. (2020) [31

RCT

81

ESWT

Placebo ESWT

12 (2 sessions/week)

3000

---

5

12-20

I

Geyik (2021) [23

RCT

184

ESWT

ESWT + PRP

5 (1 session/week)

1800

70

---

0.09

I

Ortac et al. (2021) [29

RCT

66

ESWT

Placebo

4 (1 session/week)

3000

30

5

0.20

I

Shendy et al. (2021) [25

RCT

42

ESWT + PFMT

Placebo ESWT + PFMT

12 (2 sessions/week)

3000

---

---

0.09

I

Motil et al. (2022) [30

RCT

32

ESWT

Placebo

4 (1 session/week)

4000

10

8

0.16

I

  1. P Pulses per session, D Depth of the application, F Frequency of the application, LE Level of evidence, QES Quasi-Experimental study, CS Controlled study, RCT Randomized controlled trial, QES Quasi-experimental study, ESWT Extracorporeal shock waves therapy, PDEI-5 Phosphodiesterase type five inhibitor drug, PFMT Pelvic Floor Muscle Training, –- Not described